Yay or Nay?

[meeks]

Please help me decide between these two bags, or just say neither if you don't find either of them appealing. Thanks!

#1

#2

zappos

 

[Wenxin]

#1 gets my vote!

It reminds me of a little grey Louis Vuitton speedy Alexa Chung carried not too long ago.

 

[Legyviel]

meeks, nay to both, sorry.

 

[indepwe]

Nay to both, they look cheap.

 

[oiselet]

If I were to pick any it would be number 1, but nay to both. Sorry.

 

[lifeistiffanyblu]

NAY to both sorry..looks cheap to me aswell.especially the second one.

 

[Aby]

I received an offer to buy this shearling coat from Isabel Marant. What do you think?
(ebay)

 

[John_M.]

I'll go with (very slight) Yay! for the first handbag, and Nay! to the second. I agree with the general consensus- both look very cheap. I do think the first one is manageable, but only so much. If you're stuck with choosing between these two, I'd pick the first one. I'd really recommend finding some better-looking handbags unless these are the two you are strongly considering.

(Moderate) Yay! to the coat in Post #1647. It's pretty cool to me. I somehow see this worn with jeans. Maybe the look I see is these paired with jeans and tucked into some chic brown leather boots (tFS veterans know I've graciously debated this look for years until I finally liked it). I still think it's a nice coat.

 

[Lapin de Lune]

I love the coat!

 

[Velony]

meeks, are any of the bags real leather? If not, nay to both.

Aby, big yay to that coat. I'm after one like that but one that is also affordable.

 

[Prescott]

Nay to the bags, Yay to the coat!

 

[oiselet]

Yay to the coat.

 

[indepwe]

Nay to the coat, looks ageing in my opinion

 

[StrawberrySpring]

^ i agree. so i say nay

 

[oiselet]

I can't decide. Karma for anyone who can help me.

All from delias.com

 

[oiselet]

Whoops, this one too.

Delias

 

[Psylocke]

oiselet Nay to all of them. Sorry. If I had to pick one I'd go for the low boots.

 

[indepwe]

Nay, I just don't like huge buckle's on things because they are really distracting but If I had to chose then the first one's.

 

[John_M.]

Let me go down the order...

* (tall brown boots, Post #1655) I'm going to Yay! those. Very nice and manageable to me.

* (taupe(?) ankle boots, Post #1655) Someone will think otherwise, but it's (moderate) Nay! to those.

* (tall taupe(?) boots, Post 1655) Yay!, but not in that color. If that's the only color offered, then Nay.

* (tall brown boots, Post #1656) You know... Big Yay! from me. The straps and buckle are nice touches, and the straps don't look like you're wearing a straitjacket for your feet.



If I had to choose, I'd go with the boots in Post #1656. It's up to you whatever boots you want to get, oiselet. Dress (and shop) with confidence!

 

[hautechild]

Aby - yay to the coat!

oiselet - it depends on what you want to wear them with but I would go with the low boots, or the third pair in post #1655 out of the tall boots.